Gamdevi/Girgaon, marketed as Marine Drive; homes sold above the 45-floor sanction. · RERA P51900050998
RERA P51900050998 · Floreat Investments Pvt Ltd (Shapoorji Pallonji) · C.S. 1552, Gamdevi/Girgaon, D Ward 400007
Overall Score5.9/10as of 08/26
A proven luxury builder and a genuine Marine Drive sea view, wrapped around a tower sold above its own sanction and a project whose developer may change hands mid-build.
Flags- Homes are being sold on the 46th floor while only 45 floors are sanctioned and registered.
The builder pedigree, owned clear title, south sea view and fair price are real, but homes are being sold above the 45-floor sanction on floor-space the approved layout doesn't evidence, a corporate demerger is pending, the build is at foundation stage, and parking and access are weak. Investigate the current sanction, the demerger and the exact-floor view before committing.
The five things that decide it
1Homes are sold on the 46th floor while only 45 are sanctioned and registered; the extra floors ride on floor-space the approved layout doesn't evidence.
2A pending corporate demerger could move the whole project to a different company before it completes.
3Both towers are only at foundation-digging on a 2031 timeline, though the payment is tied to construction, not the calendar.
4A proven luxury builder, owned clear title, and a genuine, durable south sea-and-maidan view lifted by a deep podium.
5Fairly priced for the micro-market at ~Rs.71,600/sqft carpet; the drags are deep mechanical parking and a congested doorstep.
Livability
6.0/10FairPillar score is the average of the scored attributes below; some attributes are qualitative and carry questions rather than a number.
Compound Density7.0/10
Free-sale tower, but a multi-building estate
The good news for a buyer: the sale tower is free-sale. The rehab is a separate tower on the north of the plot, so you do not share a core, a lobby or a lift with rehab tenants.
- The trade-off is that the plot is a genuine multi-building estate — two towers already built to the east and west, the rehab tower going up to the north, and the sale tower to the south, with unused floor-space still on the layout.
- Density is moderate and spread across separate buildings rather than stacked into one core.
Understand “Compound Density” on the X-Ray page ↗Neighbourhood5.5/10
Prime address, dense and busy at street level
- A dense older Girgaon/Gamdevi setting — chawls and low-rise buildings all around, an on-site sewage plant, and the cluster of towers on the plot itself.
- Prime by address, but busy and built-up at the street.
- How the immediate blocks redevelop over the holding period is the open field question, out of the sealed corridor.
Understand “Neighbourhood” on the X-Ray page ↗Peak-Hour Connectivity5.0/10
Close to the coast, slow at the doorstep
- About sixteen minutes to the nearest coastal-road entry at late morning — moderate.
- Marine Drive is close in a straight line, but the narrow, chawl-lined, vendor-congested approach lanes stretch the real drive out, so the everyday access is slower than the address suggests.
Fixable? Builders like to sell connectivity as kilometres from a landmark — but the real test is time, not distance: how long you would actually be stuck, at peak hour, just getting to a fast arterial like a Sea Link or Coastal Road on-ramp. The access route and the on-ramp are municipal and outside the developer's control, so there is no fix to offer — only an honest read of the peak-hour reality today and the area's trajectory by 2032, once the surrounding pipeline has built out.
Understand “Peak-Hour Connectivity” on the X-Ray page ↗Kitchen Ventilation9.0/10
A properly ventilated kitchen
Both kitchens open onto an external utility on the building's face, giving them a real exterior air path rather than the sealed, recirculating kitchen that dogs some luxury towers.
Understand “Kitchen Ventilation” on the X-Ray page ↗Lift Wait5.5/10
Three lifts for a tall tower — moderate waits
- The core has three passenger lifts, plus a service and a fire lift, for a tall tower at two homes per floor.
- The lift-wait model returns a middling grade — real but not severe morning waits.
- Confirming the lift speed and capacity would firm it up.
Understand “Lift Wait” on the X-Ray page ↗Water Adequacyqualitative
Water adequacy — pending the approval detail
- The municipal water and Hydraulic-Engineer tenement count that sizes water adequacy was not in the approval as captured, so water adequacy cannot be sealed from the documents to hand.
- Worth obtaining.
Understand “Water Adequacy” on the X-Ray page ↗Parking3.0/10
Deep mechanical car-lift parking — slow at peak, licensed
You reach your bay by one of two car-lifts, not by driving a ramp — a deep mechanical stack of about nineteen levels holding 176 cars.
- At the busy end of the day the retrieval model saturates, meaning a real queue risk for the whole system; the bays are licensed rather than owned and allotment is deferred to near completion.
- The reliefs are two lifts for some redundancy and the fact that no bay sits beneath a bedroom.
Understand “Parking” on the X-Ray page ↗Build Planning & Qualitynot yet scored
A checklist to verify with the builder — Rexray will score this attribute as the field database grows.
Rexray's database will, over time, be enriched with the attention to detail and quality ethos of each builder. For now, below is the checklist you should verify with the builder before you decide.
What to ask the builder- Who's the architect, and what comparable have they delivered?
- Do the lobbies need lights during the day?
- Gym/pool/lobby sized for how many residents? (gym sqft / residents)
- Does this unit's layout meet your Vastu requirements (entry, kitchen, master)?
- Can a fire tender or an ambulance reach the lobby?
- Who is actually building it?
- Mivan or conventional — and how are the tie-holes grouted and cracks controlled?
- What's the realistic floor-cycle, and how does the monsoon factor in?
- Which steel/cement? Facade glazing spec? MEP contractor? STP/solar?
- Which marble/fittings exactly? Which window system? VRV brand?
- Deck/bathroom waterproofing system? How's the facade sealed into the structure?
- Gypsum or block internal walls — and are the party walls insulated?
- Does the back-up generator power my whole flat, or only the common areas?
- Is the parking solo, tandem, or a mechanical stack — and how wide are the bays?
Understand “Build Planning & Quality” on the X-Ray page ↗Community7.0/10
A homogeneous, high-net-worth community
- A free-sale tower — the rehab population sits in the separate north tower — with homes at Rs.14 crore and up and the reputed-builder, all-cheque buyer profile.
- A uniform, high-net-worth set of neighbours.
What to ask the builder- What is the ticket-size range in the building — the gap between the cheapest and the most expensive home?
- Is the building vegetarian-only, or skewed to a single community?
- Is it owner-occupied, or investor- and tenant-heavy?
- What is the pet policy?
Understand “Community” on the X-Ray page ↗
Findings register
14 findings · severity-ranked
Every marketed claim set against the documented fact, sourced. Critical and high first.
HIGH
Registered flat is on the 46th floor -- above the 45 floors currently sanctioned/registered per RERA
MarketedA 64-floor tower; flat sold on the 46th floor
DocumentedThe registered agreement registers the sale of homes on the 46th floor, but the RERA registration and the folder sanction cover only 45 floors (6,692 sqm). Going to 64 floors needs Building E's BUA to roughly double to 12,492 sqm (+5,800 sqm) -- which the FOLDER Proforma A cannot supply (it is fully consumed; a doubled Building E would put the layout ~1,291 sqm over its permissible-with-fungible). The extra floors ride on ADDITIONAL floor area (FSI) granted by the 28.05.2026 approval, whose revised Proforma is not in the folder, and the RERA registration has not been amended to reflect it.
A home is sold on the 46th floor while only 45 floors are sanctioned and registered -- a sale above the current sanction, on floor area (FSI) the folder does not evidence.
Source: registered documents, government filings, Rexray analysis
MED-HIGH
Pending NCLT demerger may move the project from Floreat to a different entity (MHRCPL)
Marketedn/a
DocumentedThe the agreement discloses a pending NCLT scheme to demerge Floreat's undertaking and vest it in Make Realty and Construction Private Limited (MHRCPL). If sanctioned, the entity carrying the RERA registration, escrow and conveyance may change.
The company you contract with may not be the one that finishes and conveys the building.
Source: registered documents
MEDIUM
Very early stage -- both towers in foundation-digging; part-plinth Commencement Certificate with lapsed revalidation
MarketedPossession 2031
DocumentedThe sale tower and the standalone rehab tower are both only at foundation-digging stage, the Commencement Certificate covers part-plinth and its folder revalidation has lapsed, against a 2031 possession and a construction-milestone payment schedule.
The building is barely out of the ground on a 2031 timeline.
Source: government filings, registered documents, Rexray analysis
MEDIUM
Lift-wait Grade C -- three passenger lifts for a 45-floor, 2-flats/floor free-sale tower
Marketedn/a
DocumentedThe core has three passenger lifts (plus service + fire) for a 45-floor tower at two flats per floor; the lift-wait engine returns Grade C (C-to-D only at the slow corner). Better than the Phase-1 two-lift Grade-D read.
Three lifts for a tall, two-flats-per-floor tower means moderate -- not severe -- peak waits.
Source: government filings, Rexray analysis
MEDIUM
Deep mechanical car-lift parking (~19-20 levels, two car lifts) -- retrieval saturates (Grade C), licensed/deferred
Marketedn/a
DocumentedParking is a mechanical stack across ~19-20 podium levels reached by TWO car lifts (no drivable ramp); 176 bays. The retrieval model saturates at the slow end (Grade C, whole-system risk). Bays are licensed and allotment is deferred.
You reach your bay by machine, not by driving -- deep and prone to peak queues, with bays licensed not owned.
Source: government filings, registered documents
MEDIUM
Layout floor area (FSI) headroom + reserved 'additional floors above 63rd' -- future-scheme contingency + on-plot density
Marketedn/a
DocumentedThe Larger Land carries unconsumed layout floor area (FSI) and the agreement reserves 'additional floors above 63rd as may be sanctioned'. So there is explicit future-scheme-contingent BUA and room for further on-plot construction.
The tower may grow taller and more may be built on the plot -- future-scheme floor area (FSI) and added density.
Source: registered documents, government filings
MEDIUM
Narrow, congested approach roads (chawl-lined, street vendors)
Marketedn/a
DocumentedThe immediate approach roads are narrow and congested -- chawls, street vendors and traffic on Gamdevi Road and Goregaonkar Road -- so the everyday drive in/out is slow despite Marine Drive being close as the crow flies.
Getting to and from the tower means threading narrow, congested old-Girgaon lanes.
Source: Rexray analysis
LOW-MED
Rehab is a SEPARATE tower -- the sale tower is free-sale (no co-habitation); but the plot carries multiple towers
Marketedn/a
DocumentedCorrecting the Phase-1 composite read: the 33(7) rehab is housed in its OWN north tower, so the sale tower is FREE-SALE with no rehab co-habitation, no shared core/lift with rehab tenants. The trade-off is a multi-building estate -- JK (east, built), a west tower (built), the rehab (north) and the sale (south) share the Larger Land.
You don't share your building with rehab tenants -- but you share the plot with several towers.
Source: Rexray analysis, government filings, registered documents
LOW-MED
Inland Gamdevi/Girgaon address marketed as 'Marine Drive'
Marketed'The Odyssey, Marine Drive'
DocumentedThe project is registered at Gamdevi/Girgaon (inland of Marine Drive) but branded 'The Odyssey, Marine Drive'. The sea/Marine-Drive VIEW is genuine for the habitable floors (south deck over Chowpatty/Back Bay), so this is an address-branding upgrade rather than a false view claim.
The 'Marine Drive' branding upgrades the registered Gamdevi/Girgaon address -- though the sea view itself is real.
Source: marketing, registered documents
LOW-MED
Vistra ITCL Rs.280 cr GROUP-level security ('Issuer 4') over the project
Marketedn/a
DocumentedFloreat mortgaged the project and its present+future development rights to Vistra ITCL as 'Issuer 4' under a common security trustee -- a group-level (not project-ring-fenced) Rs.280 cr security. Disclosed on title/the agreement/portal (no concealment), but heavier than a plain project loan.
The project sits inside a Rs.280 cr group-level charge, disclosed but broader than a single project loan.
Source: registered documents, government filings
LOW-MED
Layout efficiency ~82% held by a large shared central core
Marketedn/a
DocumentedThe full-floor plate carries a large central core (staircase + lifts + lobby + passage ~27% of the gross plate) shared by two flats, a long internal spine passage and a slightly irregular envelope. LES ~82%.
A big shared core and long spine take the plate to a middling ~82% efficiency.
Source: government filings, Rexray analysis
LOW-MED
Back-of-floor service + lift-lobby areas are common ('not owned')
Marketedn/a
DocumentedThe RERA carpet (190 sqm) excludes the service and lift-lobby areas at the back of the floor; the buyer funds that built-up as common area without owning it outright (the Rustomjee 'not owned' pattern). The decks/appurtenant terrace are disclosed and appurtenant.
Some of the back-of-floor service and lobby space is paid-for common area you don't own.
Source: Rexray analysis, government filings
POSITIVE
Genuine south/SW sea + maidan view, lifted by a deep parking podium
MarketedMarine Drive sea views
DocumentedThe deck faces south over the Girgaon Chowpatty maidan and Back Bay sea (Marine Drive / Queen's Necklace) with east/west panorama, and the ~20-level parking podium lifts even the lower habitable floors above the low-rise frontline, so the thin ABIL Mansion and low Plaza Heights in front don't block the sea aspect. Only one north service-room is walled by the on-plot towers.
The tower's real prize is a durable south/SW sea-and-maidan view, and the deep podium hands even lower floors a clear line to it.
Source: Rexray analysis
POSITIVE
SP delivery pedigree (Imperial) + owned freehold clear title + KVF pass
Marketedn/a
DocumentedSP has a real completed Mumbai luxury delivery record (the Imperial Towers + Imperial Edge, Tardeo; building Imperial I), the land is owned freehold with clear & marketable title, and the kitchens have a proper exterior air path (KVF pass).
A proven luxury builder on owned, clean-title land -- the solid base under the early-stage and structure risks.
Source: Rexray analysis, registered documents, government filings