Detailed Report · as of 09/26

Promesa Fremont

Plinth-stage free-sale tower on MHADA land, walled in and years from delivery · RERA P51900055088 (Promesa Fremont / Sale Wing-A)

Sane Guruji / Dattaram Lad Marg, Chinchpokli (Parel-Sewri), F/South, Mumbai 400012 · P51900055088 · MHADA–Darshan Properties 33(9) cluster

Overall Score4.7/10as of 09/26

The marketing sells a 'G+60' Lalbaug tower with skyline views; the record is a plinth-stage free-sale tower on unowned MHADA and municipal land, ringed by taller neighbours and outnumbered two-to-one by rehab on its own plot, built by a first-time developer against a 2030 date.

Flags
  1. A plinth on a 2030 date: above-plinth work is barred until the final MHADA NOC and payments, and the sale OC waits on ~460 rehab homes.

Investigate. The apartment is genuinely fine - carpet-only with no unownable common area, external-air kitchens, adequate lifts, drive-to-bay parking, priced in line with the mill-land market - and the land is a top-grade MHADA leasehold (fresh 90 years, token renewal, clean charge), not the drag it first looks. The one real deal-breaker is delivery: only a plinth CC exists, the free-sale OC is gated on ~460 rehab homes being delivered, the builder is unproven, and the good lease is not yet vested (conveyance waits on the whole cluster). Wait for above-plinth sanction and OC visibility before committing.

The five things that decide it
1The tower is a plinth. Only a plinth-level Commencement Certificate is in hand; above-plinth work is barred until the final MHADA No-Objection Certificate and payments, the builder is a first-time name in our Chinchpokli set, and the free-sale Occupation Certificate cannot issue until ~460 rehab homes across the plot are delivered — against a 2030 date.
2The land is a 90-year MHADA lease (renewable at a token Rs.11/year, so no expensive renewal) - but it is leasehold, not freehold, and the free-sale society's conveyance vests only after the ENTIRE rehab-plus-sale cluster completes; two 2023 High Court matters sit unexplained.
3On its own 6,609 sqm plot the free-sale tower is the minority use — about 460 rehab and MHADA homes across two wings and a retained building sit around ~224 sale flats, a roughly two-to-one rehab-to-sale ratio.
4The view is hemmed in: taller neighbours ring the tower on every premium side — Minerva (~301 m) west, the 300 m-plus Mahalaxmi cluster south-west, and the BDD Chawl 250 m-plus sale towers on the marketed north-west aspect — so there is no protected long view; the eastern low-rise side is the best it gets.
5The home itself is sound — a carpet-only apartment with no unownable 'exclusive' common area, external-air kitchens and enough lifts for a comfortable wait, priced in line with the Chinchpokli/Lalbaug mill-land market.
FVL — Rexray's index · F Fundamentals · V Value · L Livability · each pillar is the average of its scored attributes, scored 0–10: Weak (<4) · Mixed (4–6) · Fair (6–7.5) · Strong (7.5+) · the verdict is set separately, by hard-stop rules · Scoring Methodology →

Fundamentals

4.2/10Mixed

Pillar score is the average of the scored attributes below; some attributes are qualitative and carry questions rather than a number.

Clear Title5.5/10
A top-grade MHADA leasehold - not yet vested, and litigation-shadowed
  • Freehold is the ideal but not the Mumbai norm, so the lease is graded on its own cleanliness - and this is about as clean as a government leasehold gets.
  • MHADA, which has owned the plot freehold since 1977, grants a fresh 90-year lease that renews on a renewal clause at a token Rs.11 a year, with no expensive market-rate renewal, and takes its consideration in built area (its own wing of the scheme) rather than ongoing rent.
  • The charge is clean - no mortgage on the project in the registered agreement.
  • That is a top-grade leasehold, only a notch or two below a clean freehold.
  • Two property-specific things hold it a little lower.
  • The tenure is not yet vested: the free-sale society's lease is executed only after the entire rehab-plus-sale cluster is complete and occupied, so a buyer today holds the promise of a clean lease rather than one in hand - a risk that mostly belongs to delivery.
  • And the portal flags two 2023 High Court matters with no papers on file.
  • Clear those and this reads as a genuinely sound leasehold.
An older fight over this scheme (MHADA cancelled the developer's NOC in 2014) ran to the Supreme Court and was resolved in the developer's favour in 2021; the two 2023 High Court matters are separate and unexplained. MHADA has owned the main plot since 1977, so the 90-year lease it grants is fresh - not a residual nearing expiry.
What to ask the builder
  • What are the two 2023 Bombay HC matters, and when does the free-sale society lease actually get executed relative to the rehab completion?
Understand “Clear Title” on the X-Ray page ↗
Delivery3.0/10
A plinth on a 2030 promise, by a first-time developer
  • Only a plinth-level Commencement Certificate is in hand.
  • Above-plinth construction is barred until the developer obtains the final MHADA No-Objection Certificate and clears the scheme payments, and - crucially - the free-sale Occupation Certificate cannot be granted until every rehab occupant across the plot is re-housed and the rehab building is complete (within 36 months of its own Commencement Certificate).
  • Possession is set for end-2030, and the developer is a first appearance in the Rexray set with no track record of completed, occupied towers we can point to.
  • On top of that the floor area (FSI) is not fully consumed - the agreement itself says further floor area (FSI) 'will be proposed and consumed in future' - so part of the upper tower rides on approvals not yet granted.
  • This is the single biggest risk on the property.
What to ask the builder
  • Is any above-plinth CC in hand yet, and what is the status of the rehab re-housing that gates the free-sale OC?
Understand “Delivery” on the X-Ray page ↗
Developer Compliance5.0/10
An average, active record - on a portal with data faults
  • The registration is active with quarterly architect and engineer certificates filed to mid-2026, and legibility is average.
  • Worth knowing that the portal record itself carries faults a reader must correct: the published map coordinate is off by about a degree (it would place the plot ~110 km north), the parking table renders as all-zeros, and the Commencement Certificate table is blank even though a Commencement Certificate chain exists in the documents.
Understand “Developer Compliance” on the X-Ray page ↗
Brochure-vs-Reality3.5/10
'Lalbaug', 'G+60' - the marketing rounds up
  • Three claims sit above the record.
  • The address is marketed as 'Lalbaug', a trendier neighbour of the registered Chinchpokli/Parel-Sewri.
  • The height is sold as 'G+60' with a 47th-floor flat, while the sanctioned area statement accounts habitable floors only to about the 37th - the higher numbers count podium levels in and skip unlucky floors.
  • And the tower is shown standing alone, when it is the minority building on a plot roughly two-thirds given to rehab.
Understand “Brochure-vs-Reality” on the X-Ray page ↗

Value

5.6/10Mixed

Pillar score is the average of the scored attributes below; some attributes are qualitative and carry questions rather than a number.

View4.0/10
Ringed by taller towers - no protected view
  • The tower is surrounded by neighbours taller than its own roof.
  • Due west stands Minerva at about 301 m; the south-west has the 300 m-plus Mahalaxmi cluster; the north has Avighna and The Edge at ~260-270 m; and the primary marketed north-west aspect looks straight at the BDD Chawl redevelopment's 250 m-plus sale towers.
  • The lower and mid floors are additionally walled by the project's own rehab wings to the north and east.
  • So there is no protected long-range view in any of the premium directions.
  • The most open aspect is actually the eastern, lower-rise Byculla/railway side.
  • Which flat you buy - its face and floor - decides the outlook entirely.
Today: Hemmed in by a ring of taller neighbours; best aspect is the eastern low-rise side.By 2032: The BDD Chawl 250 m+ sale towers on the north-west, if built to sanction, close the primary marketed aspect further.
Promesa Fremont — the plot and what surrounds it
Rexray View Map: Promesa Fremont and its surrounding development
What to ask the builder
  • Which way does this specific flat face, and on what floor - the only open aspect is east/low-rise.
Understand “View” on the X-Ray page ↗
Layout & Living5.0/10
A below-average butterfly plate
  • The floor is a pinwheel: a big central core with several lift banks, and slender angled arms carrying eight or nine homes (700-1050 sqft) per level.
  • That shape spends more of the floor on circulation and perimeter, so usable efficiency computes to the low-to-mid 60s percent - below the Parel-Sewri set average.
  • Private decks are a plus; the exact interior-column count in the living rooms is the one thing left to confirm off the sanctioned plate.
What to ask the builder
  • The west-face glass specification — brand, glazing thickness, and the heat-trapping (SHGC / U-value) number.
Understand “Layout & Living” on the X-Ray page ↗
Non-RERA Area7.5/10
A clean apartment - nothing unownable sold to you
  • The reference flat is carpet-only: 1044 sqft of RERA carpet, with no separate deck or enclosed 'exclusive-use' area dressed up and sold as part of the home.
  • The building's common areas and amenities - lifts, staircases, landings, tanks, gym, banquet hall - stay with the promoter as common property, not carved out onto your agreement.
  • That means no restricted-common-area trap on this unit, which is a genuine positive.
Understand “Non-RERA Area” on the X-Ray page ↗
Pricing6.0/10
Priced in line with the mill-land market
  • The registered agreement works out to about Rs.28,762 per sqft of carpet (Rs.3.0 crore for the 1044 sqft flat), and the field band is roughly Rs.25,800-31,800.
  • That is in line with the Chinchpokli/Lalbaug mill-land micro-market - neither a bargain nor a stretch.
  • Whether any part of a transaction runs in cash is unconfirmed.
What to ask the builder
  • What is the all-in cost — including stamp duty, registration and goods-and-services tax (GST)?
  • What is the rate on the area I actually own (carpet plus deck) versus the marketed area?
  • What have recent apartments in this building / micro-market actually registered at?
Understand “Pricing” on the X-Ray page ↗

Livability

5.1/10Mixed

Pillar score is the average of the scored attributes below; some attributes are qualitative and carry questions rather than a number.

Compound Density3.0/10
The minority tower on its own plot
  • On the 6,609 sqm plot the free-sale tower is outnumbered by rehab.
  • Around 224 sale flats sit alongside roughly 460 rehab and MHADA homes - about 205 in the rehab wing, 162 in the MHADA wing, and 93 in a retained older building - a rehab-to-sale ratio near two to one.
  • That is a lot of density, footfall and shared-compound life around the sale tower, and the rehab wings also block the lower floors' north and east views.
Understand “Compound Density” on the X-Ray page ↗
Neighbourhood4.0/10
A dense, mid-redevelopment mill-land belt
  • The surroundings are an actively redeveloping mill-land district: the project's own rehab and MHADA masses, plus a ring of supertall towers going up nearby, mean heavy density and construction for years to come.
  • The wide 36.6 m Sane Guruji Marg frontage helps.
  • How the surrounding pipeline lands over the next few years is a field question.
Understand “Neighbourhood” on the X-Ray page ↗
Peak-Hour Connectivity4.5/10
Inland - slow to the sea, quicker to the freeway
  • It is an inland location.
  • The nearest coastal-road entry (Haji Ali) is about 35 minutes on a weekday late morning, while the Eastern Freeway / Atal Setu junction is nearer at about 20 minutes.
  • Good for the eastern harbour side and the airport run, weak for the western sea-facing corridor.
Fixable? Builders like to sell connectivity as kilometres from a landmark — but the real test is time, not distance: how long you would actually be stuck, at peak hour, just getting to a fast arterial like a Sea Link or Coastal Road on-ramp. The access route and the on-ramp are municipal and outside the developer's control, so there is no fix to offer — only an honest read of the peak-hour reality today and the area's trajectory by 2032, once the surrounding pipeline has built out.
Understand “Peak-Hour Connectivity” on the X-Ray page ↗
Kitchen Ventilation9.0/10
Kitchens breathe outside - pass
  • The kitchens sit on the outer edge of each arm with a service slab or utility balcony beside them, so they vent to open air rather than recirculating indoors.
  • A clean pass on ventilation.
Understand “Kitchen Ventilation” on the X-Ray page ↗
Lift Wait6.5/10
Enough lifts for a comfortable wait
  • The core runs about six passenger lifts for the eight or nine homes on each floor, over a tall stack.
  • The modelled peak-hour wait lands in the good-to-adequate band (around 23-35 seconds), so the lift experience is not a problem at this price.
  • The exact lift speed and car size would confirm it precisely.
Modelled peak interval ~23-35 s across the mid-market lift band - Grade A-to-B.
Understand “Lift Wait” on the X-Ray page ↗
Water Adequacyqualitative
Water sanction not legible - ask
  • The water-connection count that the municipal sanction ties to the number of homes was not legible in the documents we have, so water adequacy can't be sealed from the folder.
  • Worth asking the builder for the sanctioned water/hydraulic No-Objection Certificate against the unit count.
What to ask the builder
  • What is the sanctioned water/hydraulic NOC connection count against the number of flats?
Understand “Water Adequacy” on the X-Ray page ↗
Parking5.0/10
Drive to your bay - but up a tall podium
  • Parking is genuine self-park: you drive up a 7.60 m two-way ramp to a podium bay, with some double-deck (stack) bays on the decks.
  • There are plenty of spaces (about 387 against a requirement of 269).
  • The catch is height - the podium climbs perhaps ten to fifteen levels on a single two-way ramp with no car lift, so an upper-deck bay means real ramp time each way.
  • The bay is allotted only near handover, and a private-bay EV charger is not confirmed.
What to ask the builder
  • Which podium level and bay is allotted to this flat, and is a private-bay EV charger permitted?
Understand “Parking” on the X-Ray page ↗
Build Planning & Qualitynot yet scored
A checklist to verify with the builder — Rexray will score this attribute as the field database grows.

Rexray's database will, over time, be enriched with the attention to detail and quality ethos of each builder. For now, below is the checklist you should verify with the builder before you decide.

What to ask the builder
  • Who's the architect, and what comparable have they delivered?
  • Do the lobbies need lights during the day?
  • Gym/pool/lobby sized for how many residents? (gym sqft / residents)
  • Does this unit's layout meet your Vastu requirements (entry, kitchen, master)?
  • Can a fire tender or an ambulance reach the lobby?
  • Who is actually building it?
  • Mivan or conventional — and how are the tie-holes grouted and cracks controlled?
  • What's the realistic floor-cycle, and how does the monsoon factor in?
  • Which steel/cement? Facade glazing spec? MEP contractor? STP/solar?
  • Which marble/fittings exactly? Which window system? VRV brand?
  • Deck/bathroom waterproofing system? How's the facade sealed into the structure?
  • Gypsum or block internal walls — and are the party walls insulated?
  • Does the back-up generator power my whole flat, or only the common areas?
  • Is the parking solo, tandem, or a mechanical stack — and how wide are the bays?
Understand “Build Planning & Quality” on the X-Ray page ↗
Community4.0/10
A mixed, transitional community
  • By its make-up this is a mixed community: a roughly two-to-one rehab-to-sale plot in a redeveloping mill-land pocket, with compact two- and 2.5-bedroom sale homes around three crore.
  • Whether the sale buyers skew end-user or investor is hard to call on the ground today.
What to ask the builder
  • What is the ticket-size range in the building — the gap between the cheapest and the most expensive home?
  • Is the building vegetarian-only, or skewed to a single community?
  • Is it owner-occupied, or investor- and tenant-heavy?
  • What is the pet policy?
Understand “Community” on the X-Ray page ↗

Findings register

10 findings · severity-ranked

Every marketed claim set against the documented fact, sourced. Critical and high first.

HIGH
Plinth-only Commencement Certificate on a 6-year-out, first-in-Parel-Sewri set developer
Marketed[MKT] Under-construction tower
Documented[GOV] The only Commencement Certificate is plinth-level (13/12/2023 + amends); LOI condition 11 bars Commencement Certificate above plinth until the final MHADA No-Objection Certificate + DA + payments; possession 31/12/2030; Darshan Properties has no Parel-Sewri set track record.
MED-HIGH
Floor-number inflation + floor area (FSI) not fully consumed (upper portion contingent)
Marketed[MKT]/the agreement the agreement reference unit on the 47th-floor label; marketing plates to the 40th+ floor
Documented[GOV/REG] Sanctioned floor area (FSI)/BUA area statement accounts Wing-A residential to its 37th-floor row; RERA site sanction = 56 total levels (=~19 base/podium + 37 habitable); marketing/the agreement use inflated floor NUMBERS ('47th floor', 'G+60'). the agreement recital NN: floor area (FSI) 'not fully consumed... further floor area (FSI) will be proposed & consumed in future'. Combined with the plinth-only Commencement Certificate.
MED-HIGH
Heavy on-plot rehab load around the sale tower
Marketed[MKT] Standalone tower depiction
Documented[GOV] ~280 Bawala-Compound tenants + 4 C.S.3 occupants rehoused across Rehab Wing-B (33 floors), MHADA Wing-C (162 tenements, 28 floors) and the retained D-1 (93 tenements, G+7) on a 6609 sqm plot.
MED-HIGH
Ringed by taller neighbours - no protected view
Marketed[MKT] Open/skyline views
Documented[REXRAY-FIELD] Surrounded by supertalls taller than the subject's own top: Minerva ~301 m (W), 7 Mahalaxmi ~300 m+ (SW), BDD Chawl 250 m+ sale towers (north-west, on the primary marketed aspect), Edge ~268 m + Avighna ~260 m (N). Lower/mid floors also walled by on-plot rehab (N/E).
MEDIUM
Leasehold government land - but a benign 90-year lease
Marketed[MKT] Ownership implied
Documented[REG] MHADA (C.S.2) + BMC (C.S.3) land under 33(9); the JV/DA (BBE2-21842-2023) grants a fresh 90-YEAR MHADA lease, renewable at Rs.11/year (nominal), with MHADA compensated by a built-area share (its wing) + premiums - no expensive renewal, no heavy ground rent. But leasehold not freehold, and the free-sale society's conveyance vests only after the entire cluster completes.
MEDIUM
Below-average butterfly plate
Marketed[MKT] Efficient layouts
Documented[GOV] Pinwheel/butterfly plate with a large multi-lift central core and slender arms; LES ~62-70% vs Nautilus 74% / Trilogy 81%.
MEDIUM
Two 2023 High Court matters, no papers
Marketed[MKT] Clear title
Documented[REG] Portal 'Litigation: Yes' - Bombay High Court 31022/2023 and 19114/2023 - but no cause-papers in the dump; nature/parties unknown (the older No-Objection Certificate-cancellation chain resolved at the Supreme Court in 2021).
LOW-MED
Marketed as 'Lalbaug'
Marketed[MKT] 'Promesa Fremont / Lalbaug'
Documented[REG] Registered locality is Chinchpokli / Parel-Sewri, F/South Ward.
LOW
Encumbrance uncorroborated / the building approval water count not read
Marketedn/a
Documented[REG] Portal 'Encumbrance: No' rests on self-declarations; the CERSAI search is a corrupt 552-byte stub and the July-2026 finance disclosure is illegible; the building approval water/HE-No-Objection Certificate unit count was not cleanly extractable.
LOW
Portal coordinate is wrong by ~1 degree
Marketedn/a
Documented[REG/REXRAY] MahaRERA publishes Latitude 19.9886 for the plot - a ~+1 degree error (~110 km north). True location ~18.9886 (Chinchpokli). One of several portal data-quality issues (also the degenerate parking table and blank Commencement Certificate table).
Five questions to ask before you commit
  1. Is any above-plinth Commencement Certificate in hand yet, or is this still a plinth? Ask for the final MHADA No-Objection Certificate and the payment proof a higher Commencement Certificate needs.
  2. How many physical habitable floors does the tower actually have, and which floor is this flat really on? The marketing counts podium levels into the number.
  3. Which two 2023 Bombay High Court matters are these (31022/2023, 19114/2023), and are they settled?
  4. Which way does this flat face and on what floor? Only the eastern, low-rise side has an open aspect — every premium direction faces a taller tower.
  5. What is the status of the rehab obligation — the ~460 rehab homes and the transit rent — since the free-sale OC cannot issue until it is done?
Rexray — Real Estate X-Ray. This is a research view built from registered documents, government filings, and Rexray field analysis; it is not legal, financial, or investment advice. Verify every figure against the source documents before you transact.
© 2026 Rexray.AI