MahaRERA P51900049616 · MCGM P-9275/2021/(1/279)/D Ward/TARDEO · C.S. 1/279, Tardeo Division · 478.26 sqm freehold
Findings register
25 findings · severity-ranked
Every marketed claim set against the documented fact, sourced. Critical and high first.
HIGH
Half the building is rehabilitation, and the sale agreement never says so
MarketedThe registered agreement describes 'The Project known as Servai Tower... consisting of Ground Floor and 21 Upper Habitable Floors with Tower Parking' and nothing else.
DocumentedRehabilitation takes 1,488.08 sqm of the 2,970.37 sqm envelope — 50.1 per cent. The words 'cess', 'cessed', '33(7)', 'rehab', 'rehabilitation' and 'tenant' appear nowhere in the agreement's operative body; the only trace is recital F's bare reference to 'sanction from MHADA and MCGM'. The title report, by contrast, states plainly that the building being replaced was 'fully occupied... by tenants/occupants'.
A buyer reading the sale agreement end to end would not learn that this is a cessed-building redevelopment in which rehabilitation households take half the floor area and share the entrance, lifts and staircase.
Source: registered documents, government filings
MED-HIGH
The MahaRERA record is keyed to a sanction three vintages out of date, and shows no certificate for a building that has been fully occupation-certified since February 2026
MarketedPortal shows the project Active, permissible built-up 3,343.10 sqm, sanctioned 3,179.96 sqm, 17 apartments, 21 covered parking bays, an empty commencement-certificate table and no occupation certificate.
DocumentedThose built-up figures are EXACTLY the superseded 2021 Proforma A. The 2023 amended sanction reads 2,970.37 permissible and proposed excluding fungible, 4,009.99 and 3,842.57 including it — and the governing sanction is the Tardeo set of 27-Sep-2024, later still. The sanctioned Parking Statement counts 24 flats and proposes 48 bays. Four commencement-certificate endorsements exist, ending in a full certificate for the entire work. A full occupation certificate issued on 05-Feb-2026.
Everything quantitative on the public record for this building is wrong, because the promoter never re-declared after amending the plans — and the record still shows no completion certificate for a building that has been finished and certified for six months.
Source: registered documents, government filings
MED-HIGH
Three flats in the building stand mortgaged to a tenants' association, disclosed to the regulator and to no one else — and invisible to a charge search
MarketedThe MahaRERA portal states there is no financial encumbrance. The registered agreement warrants that 'There are no encumbrances upon the Real Estate Project except those disclosed to the Allottee/s' and the allotment letter states the unit 'is free from encumbrances'.
DocumentedThe promoter's own declarations, twice, disclose an 'Indenture of Mortgage dated 23.08.22 executed as a security towards cost of construction of the Rehab area by way of mortgage of Flat No. 1301, 1302 & 1401 in favour of Servai Building B Tenants Association'.
Three specific flats were pledged to a tenants' body to secure the cost of building the rehabilitation area; nothing about it reaches the sale agreement, and no charge search will ever find it.
Source: registered documents
MED-HIGH
Two lifts for twenty-one floors, one staircase, and no rating that fixes it
MarketedThe marketing plates show the two lifts accurately.
DocumentedTwo passenger lifts at 2.13 by 2.10 m and one dog-leg staircase serve ground plus twenty-one floors, including six floors of commercial units. At the field-confirmed one to two metres per second the interval is fifty-six to a hundred seconds - Grade D on three of the four corners of the band.
The core is thin for the height, and the problem is the number of cars rather than their speed.
Source: government filings
MED-HIGH
The outlook is closing: one arc already blocked, two named towers coming on the west, and the south to be built out
MarketedThe renders place the tower among low-rise leafy villas with open water in the middle distance and claim no named view.
DocumentedNorth-east is already blocked by a recently completed building slightly taller than this one. West is protected at the plot line by Girton School but will be occupied beyond it by Lodha Marq (33 storeys, possession 2027) and MICL Aaradhya Avaan (possession 2030). South will be blocked on most floors by Wallace Apartments. East is a dead wall — no habitable room faces it. North and north-west are clear today over low-rise New Chikhalwadi society stock.
Of eight arcs, one is gone, one is a blind wall by design, one has two towers approved or building on it, one is due to be blocked, and the two that remain open are open over exactly the stock that redevelops.
Source: Rexray analysis, secondary sources, registered documents
MED-HIGH
One machine moves every car in the building
MarketedThe registered Second Schedule calls it 'Tower Parking'.
DocumentedA single retrieval machine serves an automated stack of 48 sanctioned bays running from a pit below plinth up through the 5th floor. There is no ramp anywhere in the building.
There is no second machine and no ramp, so a single mechanical failure takes out the parking for the whole building at once.
Source: government filings, Rexray analysis
MEDIUM
The only registered sale agreement in the folder is a promoter-side transaction — the buyer signs the promoter's own regulatory filings
Marketedn/a
DocumentedThe purchaser named in the registered agreement of 31-Mar-2026 digitally signs the promoter's Form 1 of April 2025 under 'Signature of Promoter — Name: Inclineestate Developers LLP'; is listed among the project's registered professionals on the MahaRERA portal; gives an email address on the promoter group's own domain in the Seventh Schedule; and gives a residential address in the same Marine Drive building that heads the promoter's partner declaration.
Four independent documents in the same folder place the buyer on the promoter's side of the table, so the price on this instrument is not a market observation.
Source: registered documents
MEDIUM
Five of the twenty-one floors above the entrance hold cars, and the elevation renders draw them as homes
MarketedThe elevation renders carry an unbroken glazing and balcony rhythm from the entrance canopy to the parapet.
DocumentedGround is a double-height lobby with meter and pump rooms; the 1st to 5th floors are an automated car stack with part-floor non-residential rehabilitation units; a service floor sits above them; homes begin at the 6th.
The building reads as twenty-one storeys of apartments and is sixteen, with five levels of machine-parked cars underneath.
Source: government filings, marketing
MEDIUM
Sixteen per cent of the building's floor area is imported from another property, and no document in the folder says which
Marketedn/a
Documented494.00 sqm of the 2,970.37 sqm permissible envelope is clubbing floor area (FSI). The agreement reserves to the promoter floor area (FSI) 'acquired through clubbed scheme as per DCPR 2034'. The clubbing instrument is not in the folder and the source property is not named anywhere.
About one sixth of the sanctioned floor area came from somewhere else, and the folder does not say where or on what terms.
Source: government filings, registered documents
MEDIUM
The Proforma books a rehabilitation shortfall of 166.92 sqm against a balance sale area of half a square metre
Marketedn/a
DocumentedThe sanctioned area statement records a rehabilitation deficit of 166.92 sqm and a balance sale area of 0.50 sqm.
The building was sanctioned owing 167 square metres of rehabilitation area it had no room left to build.
Source: government filings
MEDIUM
Ninety-nine per cent of the price fell due before the agreement was signed
Marketedn/a
DocumentedRs.3,60,00,000 of a Rs.3,65,00,000 consideration is recorded as 'Paid before execution hereof'; Rs.5,00,000 is payable at handover. The allotment letter breaks the first tranche into a Rs.30,00,000 booking and Rs.3,30,00,000 before execution.
The schedule is not construction-linked and not calendar-linked; it is a single payment before signature.
Source: registered documents
MEDIUM
The apartments are sold as bare shells and the headline rate does not say so
MarketedThe renders show fully furnished interiors — fitted kitchens, wardrobes, finished bathrooms, timber floors.
Documented'The Units shall consist of bare flat without any internal finish save and except windows and main door.'
What is delivered is a concrete box with windows and a front door; every surface and fitting in the marketing images is a separate cost the purchaser carries.
Source: registered documents
MEDIUM
There is no ramp: every car in the building is placed and retrieved by machine, through a stack five floors deep
MarketedThe registered Second Schedule calls it 'Tower Parking'. The renders show a conventional street entrance.
DocumentedA fully automated stack runs from a pit about three metres below plinth up through the 1st to 5th floors, cars on shuttling pallets three deep either side of a central shaft, retrieved by one machine, entered off a 6.30 m driveway and a turntable. No vehicular ramp exists anywhere. The statement proposes 48 bays against 39 required and the agreement grants two spaces per apartment.
Tier E access — the owner never drives to their own bay — on a system whose morning queue is a real but modest cost for seventeen families.
Source: government filings, registered documents
MEDIUM
The building's only vehicular access is a shared private passage, not a public road
Marketedn/a
DocumentedCadastral Survey No. 3/279 is 'a common passage for the holders of land bearing Cadastral Survey No. 279, 1/279 (i.e. Land), 2/279 and 312 of Tardeo Division'. The right conveyed to the promoter is a right to USE it, shared with four holdings, together with 'any benefits or rights attached to or arising therefrom, including floor area (FSI), Transfer of Development Rights'.
Access is a right of way over land the promoter shares with four neighbours, entered through a removable bollard — not a municipal street.
Source: registered documents, government filings
MEDIUM
The property register card has never been mutated into the developer's name — five years after the conveyance
Marketedn/a
DocumentedThe property register card records the trustees and the three original family holders in equal quarter shares. The LLP applied to the Superintendent of Land Records to mutate its name on 15-Sep-2021. The registered agreement of 31-Mar-2026 still says only that 'The Promoter has applied to the appropriate authorities for recording its name in the Property Register Card'.
The revenue record still shows a family that sold the land in February 2021.
Source: registered documents
MEDIUM
The advocate's own search report says nearly four decades of records may not be reflected
MarketedA 73-year title search, 1950 to 2022.
DocumentedThe report lists no entries for 1950-1952, 1954-1962, 1966-1970 and 2012-2019; torn pages for 1963-1965, 1976, 1978-1985, 1998 and 2000-2005; partly torn pages for 1971, 1973-1975, 1986-1996 and 2006-2011; Index-II not yet prepared for 2020-2022; and gaps in the online search for 2002-2005, 2007, 2009-2012, 2014-2017, 2020 and 2022. It concludes: 'As such all the entries during the years 1983 to 2022 in respect of the Property may not be reflected in the aforesaid search report.'
The search is qualified on its own face for the entire modern period, including the years immediately around the developer's acquisition.
Source: registered documents
MEDIUM
The society conveyance window closed in May 2026 and no document shows a society formed
MarketedConveyance within three months of the full occupation certificate.
DocumentedFull occupation certificate 05-Feb-2026, so the contractual window closed around 05-May-2026. The portal's 'Formation of legal entity' and 'Formation of legal society' fields are blank. The agreement registered on 31-Mar-2026 — inside the window — refers to the society only in the future tense.
The clock the agreement itself set has run out, and nothing in the folder shows the land and building conveyed to a society.
Source: registered documents
MEDIUM
The sanctioned area statement and the completion certificate describe the 7th floor differently
Marketedn/a
DocumentedTable No-I books the 7th floor as 144.26 sqm in the COMMERCIAL column with nothing in the residential column, and books its 43.32 sqm staircase, lift and lobby share in the commercial column too. The occupation certificate describes the same floor as '7th floor (pt.) refuge, residential (pt.) & society office'.
One document calls the 7th floor wholly commercial; the other says part of it is residential.
Source: government filings
MEDIUM
Twenty minutes to the coastal road, out through a one-way loop
Marketedn/a
DocumentedTwenty minutes at 11am on a weekday from the mouth of the private passage to the nearest coastal-road entry. The building's only vehicular access is a small lane off Naushir Bharucha Marg serving this building and Girton School; Naushir Bharucha Marg is one-way, so entry and exit run as a loop.
A Grant Road West address behind a one-way street, twenty minutes from the coastal road at the easiest hour of the day.
Source: Rexray analysis, registered documents
LOW-MED
The stamped sanctioned drawings carry unresolved municipal queries on their face, two of them escalated to the Commissioner
Marketedn/a
DocumentedRedlined on the digitally signed sheets: 'Proposed with Zero open space. Needs to be reconciled'; 'Not as per C-10. Put up for approval of Hon. MC'; 'Needs to be counted in floor area (FSI)'; 'Excess area of Meter Room proposed'; 'Access to Pump Room ????'; 'Elevation Band beyond building line is proposed. Consideration of Hon. MC is requested in 4C Report'; 'Not as per provision. Needs to be reconciled'. The the building approval independently requires premium for 'Condonation of deficient open spaces' and for 'deficient width of parking spaces'.
At the moment of stamping, the floor-area accounting, the open-space compliance and the elevation projection were all unresolved — two of them referred up to the Municipal Commissioner.
Source: government filings
LOW-MED
Regulatory filings stop dead at June 2025 — the quarter the building was finishing
MarketedProject status Active.
DocumentedNothing has been filed for the quarters after 30-Jun-2025 — four quarters and counting. The last filings record superstructure slabs at 97 per cent, internal work 70 per cent, installations 0 per cent and every common facility 'yet to start', with cost incurred at 71.43 per cent.
The public filing record stops seven months before the building was certified complete, so it shows a half-finished project that no longer exists.
Source: registered documents
LOW-MED
The homes have no outdoor space at all
MarketedThe 3D plates show no deck and the renders show a glazed facade with no balconies at habitable-floor level.
DocumentedThe typical plate draws no deck, balcony or terrace — 0.45 m weather chajjas only. The Third Schedule grants carpet and car parking and nothing else. The only outdoor amenity in the building is the shared swimming pool and deck on the terrace above the 21st.
Not a square metre of private open space in any apartment.
Source: government filings, registered documents
LOW
The plot's own sanctioned area statement disagrees with the title deed by 11.74 square metres
Marketedn/a
DocumentedThe 2023 Certificate of Area gives the surveyed area as 478.26 sqm, while the area recorded on the conveyance deed, on the property register cards signed by the Superintendent of Land Records and the City Survey Officer, and on the owner's affidavit is stated as 490.00 sqm. The 2021 sheet said 478.26 in both places. Every floor area (FSI) computation runs on 478.26.
A twelve-square-metre discrepancy appeared between the 2021 and 2023 sanctions and was never explained.
Source: government filings, registered documents
POSITIVE
WITHDRAWN AT PHASE 1 — the commencement certificate is not stalled at plinth; a full certificate for the entire work issued in February 2025 and full occupation followed in February 2026
Marketedn/a — this corrects a Phase-0 reading, not a marketing claim.
DocumentedPlinth 28-Nov-2022; extended to the top of the 16th floor 20-Oct-2023 against plans of 14.07.2023; to the top of the 20th 28-Oct-2024 against plans of 27.08.2024; and to the top of the 21st including lift machine room and overhead tanks, 'i.e. full C.C. for entire work', on 21-Feb-2025 against plans of 27.09.2024. Chief Fire Officer completion certificate 04-Feb-2026. Full occupation certificate 05-Feb-2026.
The dump contained only the first of four commencement endorsements; the registered agreement carried the rest, and the certificate tracked the build all the way to completion.
Source: government filings, registered documents
POSITIVE
Delivered ahead of its own registered completion date — the strongest single fact in the file
Marketedn/a
Documentedthe building approval September 2022, plinth November 2022, 16th floor October 2023, 20th floor October 2024, full commencement certificate February 2025, fire completion February 2026, FULL occupation certificate 05-Feb-2026 — against a registered completion date of 31-Dec-2026.
A first-time single-project promoter took a 478 square metre cessed plot from approval to full occupation in about three years and five months, roughly ten months inside its own deadline.
Source: government filings, registered documents